Подтвердите e-mail

Для публикаций, комментариев, реакций и сообщений подтвердите адрес.

Публикация

I’m no socialist but this speaks to me

Обсуждение

Ответы

Communism everything is equal Fascism the rich have everything you have nothing

If you want those things, that's socialism. Make it a normal thing. America is socialist in some regards and those are the best fucking parts. 🤔

Then help make clear the difference between socialist and democratic socialist. You can quote someone who has been explaining it for forty years.

My 401(k) just took a direct hit in the trade war. One minute, I was dreaming of a beachside retirement… Now I’m Googling “how to turn moss into soup.” 📉💥🍃

That’s a very healthy and correct way to look at it. Government is a service, and it’s ‘usually’ cost effective to pool money together to provide all those services..

Seems very reasonable!

If only more people understood this!

This! If all of our services have been cut then exactly what is our tax dollars going for!

The rich are parasites living off the labors of others. We work so they can play

I'd be willing to bet you're a lot more of a socialist than anything else...

This is why the GOP & billionaire pals are trying to crash & grab the US Treasury as quickly as possible!! if enough Americans wake up to the fact that middle America has been totally scammed by the rich for the past 50 years - it could be a turning point to true freedom in America!!

Should it not happen, you should stop paying taxes. As there's no IRS anymore, who can ask you to?

He really sounds like a socialist

How can you object to the person paying for the services own them? We the people need to take it back. The billionaires can go $%& themselves until they pay their fair share.

Trump's America isn't what we ordered.

We do pay for it. And every year we get receipts from the IRS. ✊🏼

Er...

Socialist is not a dirty word in other parts of the world, only in American media. Socislism means, to me, that wealth in a society should be distributed fairly enough, so that everybody has real dignity and safety. I'm proud to have always been a socialist!

When these assholes ride around with the don’t tread on me flag they have no clue that the wealthy are laughing at them. Are they going to tell their parents when they lose their SS to pull themselves up by their boot staps??

A wealthy man's acts abusing our WH & Wealthy GOP abusing our Congress misusing Congressional Powers to force Working Americans to fund roads MEGA WEALTHY drive upon-bridges connecting those roads, water used in their mega wealth producing plants/industries/businesses/WH & Congress's PAY & utilities

Because that literally isn't socialism. Literally any economic system, people expect when they pay taxes to that system that it functions in their favor.

Exactly! One of their distraction moves. When you demand things your taxes have paid for, they call you lazy and entitled. Knee jerk reaction for most people is, “I’m not lazy or entitled, so these things must be wrong.” Learn critical thinking folks, or you will forever be the simp for the con.

Absolutely!!

I just want the free stuff I've paid for...

Government is the buffer between exploitation (corporations) and humanity (population). The taxes collected should be used to support the population. That's what government is for.

If everyone, including corporations, places of worship-POWs, and billionaires paid 10%, no one would feel it isn’t fair, and there’d be enough money for everyone & everything. Why are people who pay nothing benefiting from those paying for everything?

Absolutely. Billionaires avoid tax. Workers pay tax. It is to pay for services and provide a safety net.

J

Over half of American voters, for the first time since polling began, are open to a socialist govt, and are finally aware of the difference between ‘socialism’ and ‘communism’

It's sad you have to start this with "I'm no socialist" It should be - this is not socialism - this is democracy working for the people

Hand it over!

Need a source for social programs that actually do something for the people in the US. The Defense budget. If we took less than 2/3's of that budget say 600 billion we would still lead the world in Defense spending.

Ответ для Joseph Sacco

If you taxed the Billionaires you wouldn't even need to cut it. And if they disagree just point out that the system benefits them more, so they should be willing to pay more for its upkeep.

And No effing golf trips for “billionaires”

For Christ's sake, can we ditch the "sOciAlISTs wAnT fReE sTufF" myth already? We want workers to be paid everything that they earn, with no profit margins, shareholders, or middle-managers siphoning wages off from the people doing the actual frigging work. Kind of a reasonable aim, yes?

I want billionaires and corporations ti pay their taxes so there isn’t even a question all of this and more can be paid for.

The way that any amount of economic and social fairness (let alone empathy) is often labeled as „socialism“ or „Marxism“ or „radical left lunacism“ is really irritating to me.

Ответ для Frank‘s Take

They reframe it that way so they can get away with lining their pockets. It is such demeaning bull💩.

taxes should be fees for services rendered

Ответ для ratchetology

i should have said "are" americans seem to have this feeling that taxes are some sort of penalty imposed on people for making money

Amen to that!! What makes a great society if not the investment in it??

Its nice to live in such a country. Not perfect but nicer

Wanting to live in a civilized society doesn't make you a socialist

I am a socialist and proud of it. Socialism doesn’t eliminate wealth but ensures that the system is structured in a way that minimizes inequality and prioritizes the well-being of ALL citizens. That is why I am a socialist

Ответ для Demps

I call myself a Socio-capitalist: everyone should have food, shelter, clothing, education, work - and I also enjoy the benefits of earning a little more

Ответ для Demps

Well said & ditto. What is so frustrating is that when one looks at how humanity works, socialism should be the most sensible way to exist. But capitalism speaks to narcissism, the right of the individual over the collective good of all. It’s literally common sense. No wonder the 🇺🇸 is fucked.

Ответ для Demps

The fact that you have to BEG YOUR GOVERNMENT for EDUCATION, HEALTHCARE AND JUSTICE speaks loudly to what kind of government has been INSTALLED. Is this what winning really feels like? 🇨🇦

But isn't The Donald abolishing all taxes so that you can't argue your taxes paid for anything since there aren't any?

And the orange blob has taken all, and the people will have to take it all back and lock him up.

Exactly it’s not free when we pay for taxes

Exactly. It's what Bernie Sanders calls democratic socialism, AKA capitalism with a conscience.

Ответ для Lee in Vancouver 🇨🇦

Not just Bernie THEE most successful countries in Europe But remember $ 4trillion tax break = good Universal healthcare- socialism so must be bad Of course socialism means not working and just wanting everything for free........ if your 4

Too bad Biden and Obama votes who voted in 2024, couldn't get off their a$$es to vote for women.

The word socialism has been systematically connoted to become associated with something evil and unpatriotic when in all actuality it just means that everyone should begin on an even playing field. No in groups that benefit from structural unfairness, no out groups to persecute.

The word socialist has been bastardized by the right. Read what socialism is, then decide. They think we're communists, too. They don't understand the actual meanings of these words since people on Fox and podcasts tell you otherwise.

Ответ для Kelly Sutton (aka IglooChik)🐧

Drump calls us Fascist Communists. Which is the polical equivalent to Jumbo Shrimp, Hot Chili, or Smart MAGA.

Ответ для Kelly Sutton (aka IglooChik)🐧
Ответ для Kelly Sutton (aka IglooChik)🐧
Ответ для Kelly Sutton (aka IglooChik)🐧

Spot on. And this is why they must dismantle education. The rest of the world understands that education is the teaching of critical thinking. Republicans are on a warpath to institute indoctrination.

Ответ для Kelly Sutton (aka IglooChik)🐧

There is a difference between socialism and social programs. Kids should be able to eat. I want someone to answer when I call 911. You need roads. What i don't need is mega corps paying even less taxes but giving execs $1M bonuses.

Exactly, it is our money, not their money. And I want support for my neighbors and myself with programs that only a government can provide. I am not willing, or probably able, to get all the services I need from the private sector. We have a government to work for the many not the few.

I want what's on this post...

I didn't realize how TRULY off the rails people had gotten until I was trapped in my house, in some actual danger of freezing to death, during the 2021 Texas Power Grid Fuckup. Shitheads in my state were posting from their dying phones, saying shit like "THE GOVERNMENT DOESN'T OWE YOU ELECTRICITY."

Ответ для Ukobach

I couldn't fathom it. Like...motherfucker, you PAID for that electricity, at the START of the month. If you hadn't paid it, they would've cut your shit off. So yeah, someone owes you some goddamn electrons. But they were sitting in the freezing darkness, warming themselves by "owning the libs."

Exactly!!!

I am a socialist, I am Canadian, and what is happening to the US is what happens in End Stage Capitalism. You can’t have a predatory ideology in a finite system, you always end up at Fascism. Every fucking time, to protect the top. Happiest countries on earth are Social Democratic. Not Capitalistic.

Right there is the happiness factor difference between Canada and the USA. Socialist supports is absolutely where your taxes should go.

Exactly 👍

The Apostles chime in here, Acts 2:44-45 King James Version (KJV) And all that believed were together, and had all things common; and sold their possessions and goods, and parted them to all men, as every man had need.

Public welfare

Ответ для alwaysblue2024🇺🇸🦅🇺🇦🌻🙏🏻☮️🟧🟦

Yay , thanks for that Could you maybe keep saying it , it gives hope in the face of Americans who vote against universal healthcare in order to give billionaires tax breaks ...because Charlie kirk said that's bad socialism or they actually think Vlad is a fkn socialist

I suggest we imprison this entire administration in an absolute hell hole of a gulag and then gleefully declare we’ve finally given up on wokeness too.

Yes, one of the many reasons we all have to protest today! Join a rally -- our chance to speak our minds. (My mind has a LOT to say....) HandsOff2025.com

Hands Off!Donald Trump and Elon Musk think this country belongs to them. They're taking everything they can get their hands on and daring the world to stop them. On Saturday, April 5th, we're taking to the stre...handsoff2025.com

This is normal to want these things. I did not work my ass off all those years and happily paid my taxes for some greedy billionaire fuckers to become overlords. I want people to get help. For the first time in my life, I am witnessing the removal of public healthcare. Now I am affected.

Ответ для Peaceful Warrior 🇨🇦❤️✊🇺🇦 🇺🇸❤️

My first major interaction with "socialism" was when I was saved by DHHS in 1985. Without the govt social programs to fund child welfare and foster care, I'd either be dead or unwillingly pregnant at 12. I've fostered/adopted & am now watching every program to help foster kids be eliminated. 🤬

Neither you or the person i the post seem to understand socialism which has many forms including Democratic socialism where taxes are used to promote the common good.

This!!! 👏👏👏🎯🎯🎯🏆🏆🏆

I'm a socialist democrat, and this speaks to me. That Socialists want free stuff is a lie. Everybody would love free stuff! Most people work for it, except for the grifters.

Ответ для WHAT FRESH HELL IS THIS?!!!!

Socialism has an unfair reputation. What are libraries, police, public schools, decent roads, fire fighters, etc. if not things for the good of all of us and paid for with taxes?

That's what he's saying too. It's NOT socialist to want what you are paying for.

I'm a socialist and it speaks to me as well!

yep... it is our hard paid taxes.

I find it funny that ppl are so against socialism but yet use social media, socialize with others etc. Just crazy…

I don't understand why one of the basic perks of being a citizen of the country with highest GDP on the planet by far isn't universal health care and education. Just seems like soulless greed.

Everyone actually loves socialism because no one ever truly experienced it. If they did they’d never want to go back to backwards system like this one. Capitalists done a good job at making us hate the word for if socialism existed it would make rich more or less obsolete.

He's using the word term 'socialism' to effectively mean 'progressive liberalism'. That's become standard. It's not what the word means. It never has been. But it just is now.

They love the police but hate socialism. Meanwhile the police are brought to you by... your taxes! It's a form of socialism!

Exactly. And if I am not going to get my contribution to social security, I’m encouraging ALL of to sue! I will be owed over $163k

Ответ для Beverly

Pay no taxes. If you’re not going to receive a refund, don’t file.

the definition of socialism.

And I want all of that for EVERYONE- not just the people I like. I want maga parents to have doctors, schools, childcare, outdoor spaces, clean water, etc. ALL OF US.

No, socialists want to feed people. I'm a socialist and have never wanted "free stuff." I do, however, cringe at the sight of a hungry person... it's called being a decent human being with compassion and empathy

That about sums up my feelings.

If you're not a socialist yet there's no hope for you

When sanders ran we got accused of wanting free stuff but oddly enough when he was forced out half his supporters went to 🍊💩. Republicans like to label it as wanting free stuff so they can pocket the $ or their donors can

In a fucking nutshell

It's a philosophy - not necessarily a political dogma. If this speaks to you, you hold socialist philosophical beliefs. Regardless of what the right says, that's good. Republicans hold socialist beliefs too. We pay the military to defend all citizens. The police and fire department the same.

This isn't socialism. It's the New Deal. As American as apple pie.

Ответ для Cryptkeeper Sophie Luther

Well…I mean… Yes. It is all of these things. The New Deal was Liberal Order attempt at socialism, specifically to stave off communism and left socialism (which it worked and well) So call that what you will. I will call it imitation socialism.

Elites have got you scared. If you agree with the golden rule, critical thinking leads away from any system that thrives on inequality but not caring enough to eradicate inequality. That's where "I'm no socialist" comes from.

I'm right here for the FAA, Firefighters, Postal Services, Military, Interstates. Sign me right up.

Why exactly are you not a socialist? Capitalist propaganda?

Socialism and social democracy are better than what we have, by far. The spread between the 1% and the 98% is far less in both because of wealth distribution. Not to mention universal healthcare.

NO TAXATION WITHOUT REPRESENTATION! Bring that shit back! The whole rogue crew needs to go. They are doing things that dont represent the people. The US pays taxes that cover their salary.

Roads, water, parks, health, defense etc make sense to be payed for socially. It's offensive when the rich steal our stuff though privatisation.

Do Europeans pay high taxes? Yes, they do. In return, they get good roads, trains that run on time, free health care, free college, and a high quality of life in many ways. We get none of that, and have to support the oligarchy and Orange Cheeto on top of it all.

Seems pretty centrist if you ask me 😏

Ответ для HopefulEnigma90

For those who don’t know, this is a reference to another post and comment thread.

I believe you are hung up on is labels. Socialism is, at its core, the cooperation of people to ensure the wellbeing of the group. VOLUNTARILY! What you have now in USA, Russia & China is Authoritarianism. Whether from the right or left its manifestation is identical - COMPLETE CONTROL OF THE MASSES

Ответ для Hilary

I would suggest that what we now have in the U.S. is a blend of un-regulated capitalism, and some socialism run by an obligatory

Ответ для Hilary

Yes, and most Americans/Canadians don't know the difference between democratic socialism and social democrats Most of the time those who claim to be socialists are not, like Sanders is not a socialist!

I'm a socialist. Just want what I paid for. Nothing more.

Hard to tell is this about Socialists or Billionaires? Bezos loves delivering goods by using our roads but doesn’t want to pay taxes to help take care of them.

Yes!

Education is the silver bullet to governments led by nutcases. Everything else rolls downhill from there.

You say socialist like it’s a bad thing.. Own up to it. Everyone who cares about taking care of each other is a socialist. It’s a good thing.

In the US you see socialism as a bad thing? I think it gets mixed up with Communism which is bad. Socialism is the NHS in the UK, it's you paying in and your taxes benefiting your whole community. My taxes just paid for my friend to have cancer treatment. I love that I could be socialist for him.

You're not a socialist? Is that because you don't know the definition of socialism?

The wealthy produce nothing on their own. Without the rest of us their wealth would vanish.

👍💯

There's a difference between communist socialism and Democratic socialism. GQPers have blurred that difference. Capitalism doesn't work unless it's tempered with Democratic socialism, as we are all finding out.

Part of the concern about socialism is that communist countries (USSR, Cuba, etc) lable themselves "socialist" so people hear socialism and think communism. That's why Cubans vote for GQP, why many Americans don't understand the difference between socialism and communism so fear socialism.

Ответ для Democracy and Dog lover 🌊 🦋 🇺🇸 🇺🇦 🟧 🎀

💯

With good governance, socialism is highly effective at lifting the populace at large.

But people don't seem to care that it costs between 3-5 million PER WEEKEND for him to play golf. That is not considering that a big chunk of that is paid directly to his golf courses and resorts. He is grifting, all the while making us pay the bill. Cnn won't even say the cost.

If it speaks to you, you’re a socialist

Ответ для s o u n d e r n a v i a

My thoughts exactly.

I'm sick of seeing healthy looking people going to food banks but have expensive cars. Give me a break.

Sorry that’s not a uniquely socialist credo. These tenets are the basis of the Dem party platform.

Grifters, conmen and scammers want free stuff, you mean.

Well thought out and said. It’s what all rational people want. Well other than the rich and trumpers.

Socialists do *not* want free stuff. They want worker control of the modes of production. The very opposite of vacuous consumerist, debt-funded financialised capitalism. Social democrats want capitalism embedded in society. Not free stuff. Wages that track productivity, & investment not extraction.

The happiest country in the world, Finland, is also one of the most heavily taxed. Taxes aren't inherently bad, as long as they're used to return value to citizens that they otherwise couldn't get: infrastructure, social programs, etc. Cutting taxes just for the sake of it is short-sighted.

You don't have to be a Socialist to believe that your taxes should be used to make life and society better for the people paying them. That's not Socialism. That's just how any democratic form of governance should work.

I'm a socialist. I believe in having an efficient, well run and accountable government that collects taxes to: establish justice, promote the general welfare, provide for the common defense, and secure the blessings of liberty for ourselves and our posterity. Thats socialism

Then it seems you are in fact a socialist. Many seem to conflate socialism with communism, when they are two very different ideologies.

#AltText

Sounds like you're a socialist

Ответ для WhiskeyTangoAlphaFoxtrot

the democrats love love love them some means testing tho

Ответ для WhiskeyTangoAlphaFoxtrot

💜💜💜💜💜💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯

Ответ для WhiskeyTangoAlphaFoxtrot

I would rather help a few that don’t need it that much rather than a group of ultra wealthy who don’t need it at all.

America is the first "Pay-To-Win" scheme. Full stop.

It isnt socialism to get what your taxes pay for

What’s wrong with people like you brainwashed into name calling people that are the salt of the earth

It's not so much socialism as civilisation. Only uneducated, selfish brutes would deny public services to everyone in the community, while allowing untaxed wealth growth to a few who exploit everyone else.

Ответ для Monika FBPE

Yes!!!! This should just be basic humanity type stuff!

Get Trump and the "Heil, mein Führer" people out of our lives!

FFS, it's not "free stuff" if we are paying for it with our taxes.

(2)Debate about National debt is economic one & lot of rubbish talked about it. All nations have national debt-like overdraft or credit card: facilitates managed spending if used wisely. Whether too high involves proportionate comparison between Nations, based on GDP & expectation.

(1)Fundamental expectations of resourced society of Government. In US aim of Fed to facilitate "..life, liberty & pursuit of happiness" Not beyond its means but certainly within a realistic framework. US is one wealthiest nations so should enable better quality of life for all, not just elites.

🧵1/3 The negative light shined on socialism/communism traces back to FDR’s era. Oligarchs saw the people embracing socialist policies—and panicked. Thus began the "red scare," a propaganda tool that’s poisoned our society for decades. #classwar #capitalism

Ответ для ✊🏻The Rebel Spoonie🥄

2/ The rich realized they couldn’t hoard obscene wealth if the public demanded empathy & fairness. So they manufactured fear, painting socialism as evil. The cruelest trick? Convincing the poor to fight against their own interests. #RedScare #Propaganda

Ответ для ✊🏻The Rebel Spoonie🥄

Henry A Wallace VP under FDR-a progressive who was driven out of government by the red scare.

Ответ для ✊🏻The Rebel Spoonie🥄

Thus also began the New Deal — it was a concession to an increasingly sizeable and militant labor movement.

What Americans call capitalism is simply the rich dominating, and counter to that are the ideologies of socialism which is what most governments are built on in the first place. What’s best in every nation comes from socialism, and the struggle always stems from wealth.

Democratic socialism is the best form of government. Look at the Scandinavian countries.

Ответ для heartsonycgr

So many Americans really don’t understand what democratic socialism is and things like Fox and the Republicans try so hard to keep it that way.

Ответ для heartsonycgr

And we are happy too! 🇸🇪

Make that the centrist position. Goalpost moved. Nothing to do with socialism 😁 M4A is centrist.

Ответ для Dodie the Progressive Capitalist 💡

When society pays collectively for a universal service that’s socialism. The problem is people in the USA face eons of indoctrination with regard to the term socialism.

This individual doesn't understand what "socialism" is...it's infrastructure, roads, bridges, police and fire departments, libraries, public schools and colleges, and so much more...all the things Americans use and need EVERY SINGLE DAY.

Ответ для ScubaSuzyQ💙🦋

these are nice things but socialism is about working class democracy. we live our whole lives without any democracy at work and fake elections controlled by rich people. we get nice things when working people get to allocate the resources of society to the vast majority

Ответ для ScubaSuzyQ💙🦋

He says I hate socialism, then goes on to name the great things socialism brings But something about Vietnam

a man in a plaid shirt is holding a piece of paper in his hand and covering his face .ALT: a man in a plaid shirt is holding a piece of paper in his hand and covering his face .media.tenor.com

I wish people would say “included” instead of “free”. Like elementary school and the military and police and the postal service. Even congress and the Supreme Court are included in our taxes.

I am a social democrat. And a proud one. A social democrat cares. A capitalist does not. A conservative does not. And an economical liberalist doesn't give a fuck. The ONLY human centered ideology is Social Democratic. All other ideologies are hateful. EVERY SINGLE ONE of all the political "isms".

Its not beeing socialist its just having functional state, which in real world is more often provided by states market economies

I just love “give me it”. Grin.

But when it trickles down…. 🤪

If this speaks to you, then you are a socialist. :)

Corporate socialists want free taxes and no rules.

It's okay to admit you care about society.

Then you are, and that's ok. It's about paying taxes for stuff we need like healthcare and education. It's not that bad, say it with me: social-ism.

DITTO 👈👈👈👈👈

if they're not going to provide the states or the people what they paid for, we should stop paying for it...

Well maybe you are a socialist but you just didn't know it.

I'm stealing this!

G

The people demonizing socialism are the right wing billionaires who profit the most from an unrestrained capitalist system and who own the media companies who indoctrinate the people into believing their self serving twaddle! Democratic socialism delivers highest quality of life for the masses! Fact

Actually....you are a socialist. As are most people if they are honest and fair!

It’s only a half truth. The whole truth is “socialists just want free essentials FOR EVERYONE”

It's our money! And we want to not become homeless because we can't afford Healthcare

You don't have to be a socialist to want your tax dollars working for you.

💯 may be too low a rating.

Are you not a socialist? Or do you think you aren't a socialist because of a knee-jerk reaction consitioned by a life of exposure to capitalist propaganda?

The super duper wealthy have throughout history vilified masses of people coming together as an aberration. This era it's called communism, in other eras, Jacobian, anarchists, populists, agitators, outside agitators, etc. On and on into antiquity. Ironic that the duper wealthy claim Christianity.

Why aren't you a socialist? Would be my question lol

Capitalism is predatory, exploitative, and oppressive. An economic policy that requires profits to always go up, at all costs, is unsustainable and naturally abuses the working class.

That is socialism. Capitalism will NOT achieve those ends. #eattherich

You should be a socialist. Weird thing to brag about. “I don’t care about people”. Ok.

I want my tax dollars to help people in need not pay for one old coot to play golf each weekend.

Me too.

Amen!

Socialism was never free. It was all about pooling resources and sharing them equally. Something that psychopaths will never understand.