Подтвердите e-mail

Для публикаций, комментариев, реакций и сообщений подтвердите адрес.

Публикация

My favourite bit of the Arday story, because it combines both the humour and the horror, is that a university department doing research into education didn’t immediately go “hmm. Let’s investigate this a bit further” is the “non-verbal until 18” part.

Обсуждение

Ответы

Ответ для Hal O'Famé

I assume they looked at that and said, "nah, didnt happen, you can stop searching strava".

Ответ для Nina Baker

That picture is terrible it looks like he’s in prison 🤣

Be like telling me they’re fluent in French after never having spoken it before. Language is hard and be amazing to know how he did it so as we teach others the same way.

The worst thing about all this is the ammunition it gives to racists to slam diversity policies in academia or anywhere else. The damage it'll do to the staff and students of colour who thoroughly deserve their places at Cambridge is profound. It's shameful and heads should roll.

Ответ для Rose Byrd

Yeah that's what I keep hitting on, the profound selfishness of what he's done. Literally every Black student in the university will be given the side-eye, for YEARS, because of this, and yet he decided to do it anyway.

It's increasingly resembling the Milli Vanilli story set in academia.

My big bet is that it's going to all turn out to be some grand sociological experiment into reputation and lying. And he'll publish the paper in a couple of months.

Ответ для maxwellash

“I thought you’d just believe me: Reputation and the sociology of not checking"

The whole Arday story is kind of fascinating about the ability to develop a story of embellishments and no-one pick up on it. This is a constant of human nature and will always happen. Worthy of a book though, possibly a film. Our ability to be played. The 'confidence' man.

Ответ для Craig Nelson

My favourite exemplar is Alves dos Reis who managed to print a lot of extra currency in Portugal and it led to a financial collapse. Fascinating book about it 'the Man from Lisbon'. One should always avoid being taken in, of course, but we always are.

Ответ для Craig Nelson

"Six Degrees of Separation" handles this exact subject in a really interesting (if thoroughly 90s) way

It must have been very interesting for 7 Up to interview a non verbal 7 year old...

Ответ для Richard Chin

Particularly to do so before he was born.

Sorry, non-verbal until 11, unable to read until 18. I do a very small amount of work on adult literacy and basically if you don’t leave with good literacy it ruins your life most of the time! It’s like being professor of war studies and claiming you survived having a tank dropped on you!

Ответ для Stephen Bush

It seems his soon-to-be-published memoir was ghost written, which must be odd for any academic.

Ответ для Stephen Bush

Yeah, as a parent of a non-verbal child, this is not how it works. If someone is non-verbal at 11 (or even at 7), they are NOT going to become a Cambridge professor even through fraud. You'll be lucky if they can reliably dress themselves.

Ответ для Stephen Bush

I feel like these claims should be fairly easy to establish by speaking to those that knew him.

Ответ для Stephen Bush

Okay, this story about his childhood may not be true either. Which makes the whole mess worse but even funnier.

Ответ для Stephen Bush

I'm quite fascinated by how these stories came out. Did he just keep adding more improbable details because he wasn't challenged on the previous ones?

Ответ для Stephen Bush

Hey, that happened to me once.

Ответ для Stephen Bush

‘Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence’ is something I’d expect the average dope on the street to live by. That actual universities don’t is madness

Ответ для Stephen Bush

Rocking up at the tropical diseases unit and saying that you have natural immunity to ebola. You’d think at the very least one of your colleagues would want to *study* you.

Ответ для Stephen Bush

unable to read until 18 but still got a bachelors degree five years later too?

Ответ для Stephen Bush

"It’s like being professor of war studies and claiming you survived having a tank dropped on you!" Wow, very impressive.

Ответ для Stephen Bush

The Non-Verbal until 11 is true. Acquaintances went to primary school with him

Ответ для Stephen Bush

As a layman, I found the claim that he made the leap from "unable to read" to "doing a degree" in just two years, erm, somewhat incredible, and yet it is still on the St Mary's website.

Ответ для Stephen Bush

As Mrs Tim (previously head of a special school) would doubtless note, a child can, of course, be a 'selective mute', although obviously that's not the same as non-verbal.

Ответ для Stephen Bush

I don’t know if this is true but “please can you read this, I haven’t got my glasses” would often be code for “I can’t read or write”.

Ответ для Stephen Bush

Precisely. And the fact that the top science university fell for this fantastical yarn is all the more surprising. Balliol College Oxford (Primus alumnus splattificatus Boris Johnson) maybe..

Ответ для Stephen Bush

And he still graduated age 23 apparently. How are you meant to go from illiterate to a uni student in 2 years

Ответ для Stephen Bush

Yeah I knew an autistic kid who was unable to read at 13/14 when I knew him. Last I heard he was able to get an Open University degree in his mid 20s. No shade on the Open University, but another autistic guy got into Cambridge at 17 and the process for that was hard for him regardless of age.

Ответ для Stephen Bush

I was just going to message you about this because it has been one of the bits that has been most eyebrow raising for me.

Ответ для Stephen Bush

Was did he respond to the suprise at his first words by saying, in a strong German accent, "up until this point everything has been satisfactory"?

Ответ для Stephen Bush

Just to use a low culture example, Jilly Cooper outlines this *really well* in Rivals. (Taggie's dyslexia being both severe and not really caught/mitigated for until she is early teens means she both leaves school with one O level, functional but struggling literacy and non existent confidence)

Ответ для Stephen Bush

Yes, that’s the part that got me. How did he make up for that massive gap in his education to *checks notes* go straight to university and get a degree? At one time I worked with adults who had missed education and it took a lot of hard work on their part to get ready to start a degree.

Ответ для Stephen Bush

its feckin awful. You can sit there thinking I know it would never happen, i dont understand how it could have happened but it did for him....so maybe....one day will wake up and things will just get better

Ответ для Stephen Bush

so, according to him he learned to read and write at age 18 and then…appears to have immediately gone to college and graduated within 4 years???

Ответ для Stephen Bush

I work in special education, and my coworkers and I have encountered some smart nonverbal/semiverbal kids (no future Oxbridge professors so far), but they could all write more fluently than they could speak.

I always love to see the "why would I , a reasonable person, lie about that?" response when someone is being accused of being a pathological liar. Classic misdirection

Ответ для Jymbob
A

I imagine the specific answer to that might be: So that they can go from PhD graduate to full professorship in seven years.

Ответ для Prof Katherine Schofield 🇬🇧🇦🇺🇪🇺
A

Head down, writing his memoir from the age of 6.

Welp, I guess now I understand why he told the Guardian "To be honest with you, I thought you'd just believe me." That was his lived experience to date.

20 yrs ago I worked with one of the institutions involved here. When seriously questioning the authenticity of a student’s work , I was told that nobody wanted to convene the committee to look into it , as people were going on holiday & wouldn’t be happy … seems nothing has changed.

non-verbal till 11, illiterate till 18 I think? which still raises a zillion red flags for me but isn't quite as ridic

Ответ для BeijingPalmer

Sorry what

Ответ для BeijingPalmer

That's actually worse I think. Sometimes you get non-verbal autistic kids who learn to read and write. But if he was *also* claiming to have been illiterate, that raises so many more questions.

The bit that got me was the brain tumour surgery just before his viva, that impacted his memory, but that he still passed. I'm sorry but I don't know any PhD student who has to relearn whole chapters of a thesis in weeks and still makes it. Also was his university aware he was having surgery?

Ответ для sbolus

A blinking convenient happenstance that you can imagine helping explain him being a bit creaky and confused in the viva, though.

But all those critical skills being taught….

Ответ для David Graham

He has the details right - name of school. Heath Brook Primary School, Wandsworth. Name for the brother. Sounds authentic.

he apparently said he was in seven-up?

Ответ для whet moser

Nah. Sprite.

With so many different options I'm impressed you managed to narrow it down to just one.

Ответ для Docker

I think with all the others they’re strong contenders, but the “this is obviously subject-related” gives it an added piquancy.

The choice of outlandish claims is very interesting Why not claim 3 marathons in 3 days. Plausible enough not to be fact checked

For so called clever people they really behaved in a manner that was pretty thick!

The sad element of that is that stories like this can give a tiny glint of hope to families having a very difficult time of it so if it is fabricated/exaggerated really pretty horrid.

Ответ для Ed Jefferson

100% agree with this

Ответ для Ed Jefferson

Ooh yes. Very much like 'The Salt Path' confabulations about rare neurological condition

Most people are inexperienced at dealing with liars and inexperienced at lying. An experienced liar has a huge advantage, especially when dealing with people not looking for lies.

Ответ для Alastair Meeks

But most people who study education are not, I would hope, unfamiliar with educational outcomes if you are illiterate at 18.

It all, for some reason, keeps reminding me of that film Being There.

Yeah, it's not as if language acquisition isn't a rather well researched phenomenon, which might have had some experts' eyebrows being raised a few storeys above where they would normally be, in reaction to Arday's claim.

I can’t understand why the institution which granted his PhD didn’t routinely put the thesis through anti-plagiarism software. Every essay we submit is subject to this as a matter of course.

It’s really exposed how a lot of highly intelligent people are actually also very stupid. It’ll make a fascinating phd study into group think, halo bias etc.

When I read that I just thought, no not touching this story

Another question that never seems to have been answered is, "is he any good at teaching or discharging the duties of a professor?"

Actually he was just internalising his PhD in preparation for his big moment. Probably.

Yes. Where are his parents’ heartwarming stories? School friends? Teachers? None of his stories (incl. the ultra-running) appears to have any even anecdotal support. On the other hand, people don’t seem to have said “ooh that’s just Jason, always such a joker” either. No problem w imposter syndrome.

His primary school classmates on TikTok are laughing it up that he claimed to not speak

"It was a cave, a real cave”. In 2026 who would be a publisher (unless you are of course *a platform*)

Motor control conditions (dyspraxia, apraxia) commonly co-occur with autism, can explain speaking or writing late, and are commonly mistaken for learning disabilities or language impairment. See for example Jordyn Zimmerman at @communicationfirst.bsky.social communicationfirst.org/jordyn-zimme...

Jordyn Zimmerman’s Remarks to the Interagency Autism Coordinating Committee  | CommunicationFIRSTThe following is the text of CommunicationFIRST Board Member Jordyn Zimmerman's invited remarks to the US Interagency Autism Coordinating Committee (IACC) on April 14, 2022. The remarks were invited a...communicationfirst.org
Ответ для Andrew Kerr

See also this from @drstevenkapp.bsky.social, who was part of the DSMV autism working group. www.mdpi.com/2227-7102/13...

That's why I'm loving this story and compulsively reading updates about it: it confirms all my prejudices about education research.

Ответ для goofyasagoon

Any department that allows the three cueing system to go on for decades deserves all the prejudice against it that's possible

I recall developing a degree of scepticism for educationalists' research when I went through the HEA Fellowship/PgCGHE process in the 00s. When lots of stuff was presented to us there were quizzical looks in the room of "Yes, but how robust is the empirical evidence for a lot of these assertions?"

Everyone had that mate who (almost) everyone, knew was a complete bs merchant. There was a lad in my college who told me that during October half term his band toured Europe opening for Metallica. I'm genuinely amazed he got *that* far.

Ответ для Alex Nurse

One of my favourite a stories was a lad who lived in my friends 6 person houseshare. Everytime they'd go out to eat as a group the fellow would be quick to calculate the cost/person for everyone when they split the tab. It turned out he only calculated -5- shares and was getting free meals for years

I think it's non-verbal till 11, can't read till 18... but still. I'm waiting for that bit to fall apart under scrutiny, my assumption is that will be the denouement of the whole affair.

Ответ для Anthony Wells

somebody is sitting on a fistful of library cards

This feels like the diff between attitudes in education and academia and attitudes in actual schools.

He would make outrageous claims like he invented the question mark.

It's maybe plausible to catch up with late developing speech, over 7 years of secondary education, but how many years is he claiming between learning to read and going to university? At best he's exaggerating some level of moderate reading difficulty not reasonably described as illiteracy

Ответ для theotheories

I think it depends on whether you assume competent special needs provision… if he was always capable of learning to read but someone decided he wasn’t, and didn’t teach him, that would make a huge difference. The other statements are relevant to how likely it is in this case, but that has happened.

i didn't know what to expect when i started reading about this case -- something more subtle perhaps? but genuinely laughed out loud when i got to the list which included this, "30 marathons in 30 days" and "confronted by armed assailant in office (twice)"

i absolutely cannot stop thinking about that bit

Ответ для Neon Genesis Ewangelion

It's the "600 miles in 6 days" bit for me. Do they not have any runners in Universities? Anyone that could look at it and think "5 miles an hour for 20 hours for 6 days in a row sounds a lot?"