Подтвердите e-mail

Для публикаций, комментариев, реакций и сообщений подтвердите адрес.

Публикация

Предыдущая публикация

the fight/don't fight axis remains the most important fault line in democratic politics, and that the moderates have mostly failed to find any way to take the 'fight' side is why they are getting their asses handed to them in primaries right now

G Elliott Morris

This is why DSA candidates are really taking off now instead of eg in 2020 or 2018 www.gelliottmorris.com/p/2026-07-07...

431,8 тыс.340

part of this is intrinsic to moderation as a political philosophy - "we can come to a compromise here" is, by definition, more of a "don't fight" thing - but it's quite possible to hold more centrist political positions while being genuinely outraged at the corruption and horror going on right now

Обсуждение

Ответы

It’s theoretically possible but when part of the appeal of ”centrism” is “I dislike Nazis on my right but hate the hippies to my left” the corruption just feels liked a given that can be ignored.

KS-03 primary in August. Watch this space. Since defeating the gerrymander in 2022, Davids has done a good job trying to everything to Bolster her imagine for a KS statewide run (great, would be awesome candidate) that…just didn’t happen and now is a sitting duck for a strong Dem primary

It would be so easy. It’s a bizarre lacuna in the landscape tbh.

It's possible to hold moderate political beliefs and be a "fighter" but it's much harder to be pro-establishment and be a "fighter." E.g. you can say "taxes should be lower but also fuck Trump" but harder to say "presidents shouldn't be unaccountable & do illegal wars except when our side wants to."

Ответ для Marvo Ging

Unfortunately most (all?) of the Dem moderates are also deeply pro-establishment and they don't want to risk their own bag when the pendulum swings back towards Ds being in power.

see similar fallacy plaguing sector of old guard media that conflates “forthrightness” with bias: thinking that to state something plainly, instead of the meal mouth were used to, is biased no matte how true/hedged/apolitical the sentiment and I think it’s why eg nyt starts losing normie libs

I think Ossoff is probably the best-known example of someone relatively moderate who has read the room correctly on this.

Just do the Ossoff. It is that fucking simple. He is going to crush his opponent in a lite red state.

There's also the effects of repeatedly hearing "listen, you pie in the sky daydreamers need to sit down and let the adults in the room do what it takes to win" and then watching the adults of the room eat shit.

Ответ для insomniac

And when the "adults" do win, they never use their power to do anything that would make things better!

that's the thing; if you want to be a centrist, fine, who cares? you can be a centrist who wants to put corrupt individuals in jail, values and respects the law, and defends institutions, but you have to be willing to take an actual stance on those things, and that's where centrists fail.

Ответ для K.C. Clyburn, Author

"we should put criminals in jail for doing crimes" is actually NOT leftist idealogy. kinda the opposite if you're an abolitionist!

Ответ для K.C. Clyburn, Author

“Centrist” is a word cowards use to make their cowardice sound reasonable.

Ответ для K.C. Clyburn, Author

I am a socialist, but my ideal democratic presidential candidate isn't even necessarily a socialist, it's just someone who gives a shit and acts like it. Vote, campaign, and behave as though you care what happens to this country and the people in it. That's genuinely about all I'm looking for.

but this really is, I think, the driving force behind the DSA's success (that and having one of the most charismatic politicians of my entire lifetime in Mamdani) - it's not that voters are more lefty now, but that the DSA candidates are credibly signaling 'fight' in a way their opponents are not

Ответ для Micah

I also think calling every. single. dem. socialists for 40 years has kinda dulled that line at least in dem primaries

Ответ для Micah

the lesson the center is going to have to learn here is that "this person is too ideologically extreme" simply no longer works as a "get out of competitive primary free" card, you need to convince the voters you're going to fight harder than your opponent or they'll be happy to give socialism a try

Ответ для Micah

This is plausible, but isn’t Palestine also a clear contributor?

Ответ для Micah
M

It’s absolutely true. The first, second, and third thing I’m looking for in the candidates I’m voting for in next week’s MI primary is how they speak to fighting this administration’s authoritarianism. I would vote for a fighting never-Trump like Kristol over a feckless pro-MFA lefty Dem.

Ответ для Micah

When your rep votes to give Trump, Hegseth, and Bibi more money to kill children, you look for an alternative or you approve of genocide.

Ответ для Micah

Do Nothing politicians tend to get eaten alive by their opposition when there is a massive need to do something.

Ответ для Micah

And it’s interesting that this reality keeps getting missed or swept aside by “sour on politics” generalizations that elide the reason *why* so many people are sour, and then express befuddlement at DSA success.

Ответ для Micah

I dunno about this. Yes, there is a "fight vs deliberate" axis, but there's a neglected layer of, who are you fighting? Much of the country wants to fight Trump and Republicans. The DSA is feebly rolling that into their nebulous opposition to "the system" To fight everything is to fight nothing.

Ответ для Micah

on the flipside, this is probably the same reason ossoff — who is decidedly not DSA-inclined — is picking up steam

Ответ для Micah

case in point: abigail spanberger ran as a fighty centrist and won convincingly in virginia

Ответ для Micah

Okay but, I also think people are at least more open minded to leftist politics now. We are seeing the results of billionaires owning our entire political process amid rampant unchecked deregulation and the majority of Americans dislike that and support radical changes to remedy it.

Ответ для Micah

Loyalty is simply not one dimensional.

I know i keep coming back to him as an Iowan but Rob Sand is a moderate who basically cut his teeth on fighting and accountability as state auditor and seems to be reaping the rewards now

Ответ для Gee

its super possible to do - but most moderates are already office holders without a history of fighting, so its hard to take them seriously that they will this time