Подтвердите e-mail

Для публикаций, комментариев, реакций и сообщений подтвердите адрес.

Публикация

Why didn't the eagles just fly Odysseus straight to Ithaca

Обсуждение

187 прямых ответов · 272 сообщений

Показаны не все ответы

Публичный счётчик показывает 295, а источник передал 187. Остальные ответы могли быть удалены, скрыты или не выданы публично.

Too busy munching on Prometheus's innards.

He was too big, Ken. This is swallow/coconut discourse.

😝

Layover in Buffalo

Ответ для Lucy’s Mom

An incendiary crossover between Homer and Tolkien? This nerd is here for it.

Because that wouldn't have been realistic!

What is “dramatic tension?” Sorry, no. Calvin? What is “plot development”? Right you are! You have control of the board.

They were living it up at the Hotel California

Lord of the Rings of fallen comrades cursed by the gods.

I think you mean Sam & Frodo to Mt. Doom?

Ответ для Scott Ervin

Wait … nm

Have you seen the fees they charge lately

Eagles are very proud, majestic birds, and they are not there to be your own personal Uber. @williambibbiani.bsky.social

Back in those days, eagles tied you to rocks and ate your liver, every day.

Because Merlin wouldn't let them.

Cuz they were too busy out riding fences

He could have just clicked his heels and said “There’s no place like home”

Tush Push works better imo

His credit card was denied

[P] GO BIRDS!

Because they would be spotted by the Nazgul.

Too busy talking to the chicken

NFL CBA says you can't charter flights for free agents.

Ответ для Ben Collins

Ben.

Ответ для The Volatile Mermaid

🫢🤣🔥🔥🔥

Ответ для Just_LookingK

the Bills also insisted he visit their training camp on Minos for workouts!

Ответ для Ben Collins

Goodell doesn’t follow Zeus law. 🤷🏽‍♂️

Ответ для Ben Collins

Bud, Ken isn’t talking about the NFL team. 😂😂 He’s talking about the band

Ответ для Sheldon Corcoran

Don't be ridiculous, the band couldn't possibly carry him that far. He was clearly talking about these bad boys.

Ответ для Sheldon Corcoran

They were looking for a peaceful easy feeling?

Ответ для Ben Collins

This is a good reminder that we need more sports teams named for myth. Where are the Minnesota Minotaurs? The Annapolis Anansi? The Leavenworth Leviathons? University of Kansas Kitsune?

Ответ для David Hull 胡大衛

This disrespect of the Toronto Argonauts will not stand, man

Ответ для Squeaquy

This is the way! I hope you prioritize quarterbacks named Jason.

Ответ для David Hull 胡大衛

** The University of Southern California has entered the chat. **

Ответ для Paul Howard

Marginal at best. (*NB I'm a UCLA grad, so I'm never going to be able to give USC the credit they deserve.)

Ответ для David Hull 胡大衛

I mean, exactly which war do you think Odysseus is trying to make his way home from? 🤨 PS: ✌️

Ответ для Paul Howard

The one the Trojans lost…

Ответ для Kathy Rogers

Only because the Greeks cheated.

Ответ для David Hull 胡大衛

The Seattle Kraken say hello.

Ответ для Jenny Griffee

On that note: more cryptids, please. (...does Gritty count?)

Ответ для Jenny Griffee

This is the big trick - it's best to have something that's at least related to the area, so cryptids would be great. Gritty is indeed mythic :)

Ответ для David Hull 胡大衛

I admit to feeling a certain kinship with Gritty. Probably because of the number of times people have misspelled my last name that way.

Ответ для Jenny Griffee

Gritty speaks to us all in a singular, personal, and often disturbing way.

Ответ для Jenny Griffee

Yeeeees! This is brilliant! Tied to the area and incredibly cool

Ответ для David Hull 胡大衛

We could have had the Utah Yeti but a certain cooler company claimed copyright.

Ответ для Dan Joslyn-Siemiatkoski

Booooo on overpriced trendy cooler people!

Ответ для Ben Collins

It’s mostly Bills territory there, anyway

Ответ для Ben Collins

Well bowled, sir

Ответ для Ben Collins

Better warn Odysseus about the one-eyed monsters if he signs.

Ответ для Matthew Harrison

this could be a reference to the cyclops or to the suitors if you know what I mean

Ответ для Matunos

Oh, and I do. 🤣👏👏

Ответ для Ben Collins

Odysseus was already signed by Penelope of Ithaca.

The seagulls work for Posiden. They may not be as formidable as eagles, but they're super annoying and no bird wants to deal with them.

Because Philadelphians find it too much fun to watch Odysseus struggle (go birds!)

They were busy eating Prometheus’s liver.

Because winter was coming.

Why didn't Nolan cast real New Yorkers

They will explain in one of the prequels that the Caucasian Eagle was busy eternally eating the liver of Prometheus, the Eagle of Zeus was up to hijinx with Ganymede, and the Stymphalian Birds had all been driven away by Heracles. All that was left was a suspiciously virile swan that gave bad vibes.

Because they're from Philly and it's out of jurisdiction!

Ответ для Whatismoo

probably pre-AFC

Read somewhere that it would take 14 hrs to drive from Hisarlik in Turkey (where most scholars believe Troy was) to Ithaca. But no...had to take a leisurely cruise.

Ответ для Earl Verdant

It's all about the journey, rather than the destination?

They tried but ran into flight time limitations. Odysseus was stuck on the tarmac for 20 years

The CGI just wasn't as good in ancient Greece

They flew him to the Hotel California, and now he can never leave

I see what you did there 😉

He got stuck in the Hotel California.

My best guess is: because.

Same reason the eagles didn't take Gandalf and the hobbits straight to the Lonely Mountain. Eagles are dicks.

because they checked into a hotel that they could never leave

BC's rivalry with the Bombers was just too strong.

That would have made for a rather short and uninteresting epic poem, Ken.

ancient greek historian here: at the time there were no direct flights to ithaca due to infrastructure issues so a layover in hades was required

Ответ для andy™

Sounds hellish

Ответ для jon

The flight to Hades takes a long time - it’s really out in the Styx.

Ответ для geauxblue

i don't get any of this. it's all greek to me

Ответ для Josh

When it comes to understanding Homer, not speaking Greek is a real Achilles Heel.

Ответ для geauxblue

i'll try to learn, but i imagine it will be a real odyssey for me

Ответ для Josh

I think the eagles were between a rock and a hard place regarding where to bring him, tbh.

Ответ для Bridget Eileen Madden (she/her)

In those times, bronze age, rock was out of fashion so they said "between Scylla and Charybdis".

Ответ для andromeda

I'm keeping one eye on this funny thread and feeling sheepish I can't come up with a joke

Ответ для Nick Kellett

Nobody will get this joke.

Ответ для Nick Kellett

Maybe someone will get the point?

Ответ для geauxblue

Accommodations very Spartan as well

Ответ для Funksands

The Rhodes aren’t very good either.

Ответ для jon

its rather forgettable if you ask me

Ответ для andy™

Hades, Pearson - po-tay-to, po-tah-to

Ответ для andy™

lol - Classics major here.

Ответ для andy™

I hear they have great shining metals and sparkling gems there, but the locals aren't very lively

Ответ для andy™

Hmm... You don't seem that old to me.

Ответ для andy™

It’s cheaper to fly into Syracuse and drive anyways.

Ответ для andy™
S

It's such bullshit. They claim they can't get an eagle directly to Ithaca, but somehow there's a non-stop eagle from Olympus to a mountain in the Caucasus every day.

Ответ для andy™

They kinda did that anyways

Ответ для andy™

The particular gate for the connecting flight to Ithica was located in Tartartus (where the wicked are punished).

Gate 35X closes after torturing passengers for 24 years at DCA - The Points GuyThe new concourse opening at Washington Reagan National Airport on April 20 means no one will have to pass through the hell of Gate 35X again.thepointsguy.com
Ответ для andy™

Please answer in the form of a question.

they just play songs, dude

apparently you haven't heard the rules of hotel California

Because he wasn't Gandalf and didn't speak eagle.

Deregulation...

Because of the NASCAR.

Legend has it these were the first words of baby Diogenes

No airport. Usually we had to fly into Syracuse or more often, missed the connection and had to drive from Newark. Scranton-Wilkes Barre and Binghamton also options.

Ответ для Sebastian Gorka Izzagirre
Ответ для JBV

That reply was mostly for you. I never made the connection to Syracuse and always had to rent in Newark to make it back.

Ответ для Sebastian Gorka Izzagirre

When I started my freshman year there I essentially moved away from home, so I never really had the need to fly anywhere. Just spent summers in Ithaca (plus one summer I got a job in the Bronx and commuted from Mahopac).

Ответ для JBV

1 and 2L summer jobs were scarce in Ithaca, otherwise I would have stayed too. The summer I stayed to study for the bar was amazing - especially compared to the months of dirty snow during class.

Ответ для Sebastian Gorka Izzagirre

Summers there were awesome. I was still a teenager for much of that time, so my summer jobs were cooking at Friendly's, working for Cornell Dining, or working in group homes for mentally ill adults.

Ответ для JBV

LOL was a regular at the Mahopac Relays in the 80s

Ответ для Peter Flax

I lived there two different summers, with my gf's family. I think 88 and 89 maybe? In 1990 I moved to Albany, which I remember because road nats were there that year.

Ответ для JBV

Anyone who didn't spend at least one summer there screwed up.

Ответ для Sebastian Gorka Izzagirre

Nonsense, sir! There is the Ithaca Tompkins International Airport. I remember flying in there in a plane that held 20 passengers. The turbulence was so bad that the flight attendant strapped herself to a wall.

Ответ для Sebastian Gorka Izzagirre

Allentown/Bethlehem/Easton

Why didn't Odysseus just tack into the wind?

If the eagles are flying Odysseus to Ithaca, who is eating Prometheus's liver every day?

Ответ для elpinkogrande

Vultures

Ответ для elpinkogrande

Foodies, pissed that they can no longer order foie gras without getting scowled at.

Ответ для M.K. Iodine

Damn, yeah, you know, I guess Prometheus liver is both ethical and sustainable.

Ответ для elpinkogrande

If only it came smothered in onions ...

They weren’t in the union.

banger

😂😂😂

NO SPOILERS, KEN

Did the eagles bring him some steamed hams?

You'll have to ask The Eagles, 'cause I can't tell you why, no-no baby, I can't tell you whyyy-YYYY

They whole eagles bit is just a way to extend the narrative with a dangling sub clause.

Fuel tanks weren't large enough

New York?

I made this joke yesterday. I'm glad it was funny enough that Ken Jennings also thought of it.

NO ONE goes to Ithaca in the summer.

Kevin Patullo.

The question is always “Why didn’t the eagles?”. Haven’t you seen TLOR?

Because they were stupid

Dude.... it's not as if they had Gandalf... um... never mind.

The Greeks actually came up with the myth of Icarus to stop people from asking this question.

Maybe the same reason Gandalf didn't just give the ring to the eagles. "Just drop this into Mount Doom for me, there's a good bird. Frodo, put the kettle on." Would have made for a shorter book/film.

You're not supposed to ask the questions anymore

Ken.

They were pre-booked by Frodo and Sam

As my son tells me, "Stop poking holes in the story, mom."

Was that Week 12 in Buffalo? Completely doable…damn eagles

Because the eagles opened the wind bag and blew them off course.

Those eagles could make the Kessel run in 12 parses. Its an obvious choice.

They had some Hobbits to pick up?

Because Gwaihir would not have been able to resist the power or the One Ring, and would have become the Darklord of the entire Eurasian landmass.

Fool stop.

For the same reason they didn't tell Dorothy her slippers would take her home at the beginning of Oz: it's bad theater.

Ответ для labsoftwaredev

So the movie can happen! Wow wow wow wow...wow.

Because they aren’t like chickens and didn’t want to get to the other side.

What happened to your gollum vow of no dad jokes? Maybe Odysseus would have thought he died and it was his coming raptor into heaven ?

Also kind of pissed Homer decided not to include the glorious Tom Bombadil.

Well for one The Eagles didn’t exist until 1971.

because the Eagles are from Philadelphia and didn't want to help a Pats fan get to New York.

Because #Eagles can’t do that

DEI probably

they were too busy being the SUPERBOWL CHAMPS BABY

Because Ithaca is gorges and the eagles that big can't maneuver in gorges very well

Too busy chowing down on unlimited liver with Prometheuscode Fire10.

“Fly, you fools” was Priam telling Odysseus to hitch a ride with the Sirens after the goblins overtook Troy. It is not about Athena’s transformation into an actual eagle. God, did you even read the Fagles translation?

Brad Pitt's Troy: They Call Me... Troy!ALT: Brad Pitt's Troy: They Call Me... Troy!static.klipy.com

They were too busy rescuing Bilbo from the goblins, is how I think it went?

One does not simply walk across the Ionian Sea...

because Joe Walsh's Maserati does 185

Well that was the way it went in the original 10 page version but it turns out that the publishers demanded more.

They were busy snatching up "cup bearers" for Zeus.

Because he was a complicated man

And risk missing out on Prometheus' Daily All-You-Can-Eat Liver Buffet?

Because the Cortica Jug was held in Yankee Stadium that year.

I came here for the Lord of the Rings comparison. I wasn't disappointed.

😂

what is weight to airspeed ratio

because Gwaihir the King of Eagles couldn't make the flight calculations with the spice production shut down

How dare you bring Middle Earth into this 🤣🤣

They were in Philly at the time.

Perfectly timed post in my feed Because the eagles were busy at the beach

Crazy strong headwinds. Probably an El Niño year.

You can't fly direct from Troy, I guess.

They had to stop in Atlanta, of course.

It had to regularly fly over to peck out Prometheus' liver.

Lots of Ithaca love these days. After suffering through the Odyssey and three years of Latin (which was amazing), I was so happy with the concentration of borrowed town/burg/city names after I moved to upstate NY.

Maybe they do in the abridged version?

What, and get rid of all the fun?

Why didn’t they fly Frodo straight to Mt Doom?

i think they were stuck in a hotel or something

Odysseus didn't send them the signal by singing "Fly Eagles Fly"

M

Because that would make for a dumb story.

Because Glenn Frey and Don Henley were fighting again.

Did you know when Odysseus kicks his helmet, he really broke his toe and wasn’t acting?

Ithaca doesn't really do direct flights. Usually you have to go through Syracuse.

Ответ для Seantegrity

using Ryanair

They were stuck in an hotel in California, probably

I’m trying to write a Jets joke that involves Cortland and ICE but there’s nothing funny about ICE using the Jets’ jet

Because they were "already gone"

Because of poor media literacy, people thought the eagles' wings would fall if if they flew too close to the sun. We just assume people misremembering mythology is a modern thing but I'm sure back in the day people were always getting crap like that wrong.

this is also my critique of anything in the Hobbit

Either that or Mina’s Tirith.

Ответ для Citizen of the Galaxy

Minas! Stupid spell check!

I ugly snorted

They were too busy saving Gandalf’s ass

The TSA has him on a no-fly list...

Because Apollo would see him coming a mile away and shoot him down, I can't believe people are still arguing about this

It Odyssues fault for leaving the port key at home with Dobby

I shared this with the 14yo, and she said that the “eagles were linked to Zeus, and he had problems with Odysseus” and she’s absolutely right.

Well now the movie is completely ruined for me.

They’re not “THE Eagles”. They’re just “Eagles”.

Why didn't Elrond and Gandalf have the Eagles fly Frodo right to Mount Doom? These are the questions we ask ourselves...

Ответ для Tom McCormick
Ответ для Tom McCormick

"Humor, like a frog, can be dissected, but the thing dies in the process." -E.B. White

He was afraid of ending up in Hotel California

Because Rod Serling didn't want him in Ithaca.

For the same reason Jedis don’t seem to use the force unless it moves the story along.

Go Birds

Why didn't Gandalf just fly the ring straight to the volcano?

Because he was wait-listed.

Who do the eagles report to in the Homer-verse? I don't think any of the Greek gods are as helpful as Manwe

Antinous would have shot them down with the Ant-Wing.

I misinterpreted this as referring to the band.

Because they need to stay under the salary cap, and they have some big free agents to sign?? Anyway, I still trust Howie Roseman

The Ithaca airport only has direct flights to JFK and Dulles

Grounded by Aeolus

Because woke

Nobody said they would

Nobody goes to Ithaca, NY. The ticket was too expensive. The seats were too narrow. The Eagles only fly in Philly dreams.

Ответ для Mark Hathaway

Glad you liked it. I've heard Homer had a drinking problem and his wife wrote the Odyssey of trying to get him home from the bar. He was called Homer as a joke. He always stayed at the Bar.

Ответ для Harley Davidson 🏳️‍⚧️

They wanted to Take It Easy

Ответ для Harley Davidson 🏳️‍⚧️

Love their hit "Hotel Calypso": "You can check out any time you like, but you can never leave"

Because, it turns out that he was actually dead the whole time and that's why his wife didn't talk to him at dinner.

Ответ для Kyle Bailey

Didn't see that one coming

To get to the other side. Oh wait. That’s chickens.

Things that makes movies lousy for $100

same reason the eagles didn't just fly the hobbits to mt. doom - plot armor.

What is "because he could check out but could never leave"?